Skip to main content

The Absence of Genuine Civil Society in Post-Conflict Somalia: A Barrier to Inclusive Political Participation The Role of Civil Society in Political Transitions

Image
By

In post-conflict societies, civil society plays a pivotal role in shaping governance, promoting accountability, and ensuring that political processes are inclusive. A robust and independent civil society acts as a bridge between the state and its citizens, advocating for marginalized voices and fostering democratic consolidation. However, in Somalia, the landscape of civil society remains fragile, underdeveloped, and, in many cases, co-opted by political and donor interests. This absence of genuine civil society actors presents a significant challenge to the realization of inclusive political participation, particularly for women, youth, and marginalized groups.


Structural Constraints on Civil Society in Somalia
Somalia’s governance structures continue to be shaped by deeply entrenched clan dynamics, elite bargaining, and external interventions. While these factors have contributed to short-term stability, they have simultaneously constrained the emergence of an independent and representative civil society capable of advocating for broader political inclusion.
Several key factors have contributed to the underrepresentation of civil society actors in Somalia:

 • Political Co-optation and Instrumentalization – Many civil society organizations (CSOs) operate under the influence of political factions, serving as extensions of clan or elite interests rather than as independent voices for the public good. This has weakened their ability to advocate for systemic reforms and hold political actors accountable.

 • Security and Operational Challenges – The volatile security environment, including threats from armed groups and political actors, has severely restricted the ability of civil society to operate freely. Activists and organizations that challenge the status quo often face intimidation, harassment, or violence.

 • Donor-Driven Agendas – A significant portion of civil society activity in Somalia is shaped by international donor priorities rather than organic grassroots advocacy. While external funding is essential, it has often resulted in short-term, project-based interventions that lack sustainability and fail to address deeper structural issues.

 • Limited Civic Space and Legal Protections – The legal and institutional framework governing civil society remains weak, with restrictive policies limiting the ability of CSOs to function independently. The absence of strong legal protections for civil society actors has further hindered their capacity to advocate for inclusive governance.

 The Impact on Inclusive Political Participation
The underdevelopment of an independent civil society has profound implications for Somalia’s political trajectory, particularly in terms of inclusion. Women, youth, and marginalized communities remain at the periphery of political decision-making, lacking the necessary advocacy mechanisms to demand meaningful participation.

 • Women’s Political Representation – Despite commitments to gender inclusion, including the 30% quota for women in government, implementation remains inconsistent. The absence of strong civil society advocacy has allowed political actors to circumvent these commitments, resulting in continued underrepresentation of women in governance structures.

 • Youth Exclusion from Decision-Making – With over 70% of Somalia’s population under the age of 30, the exclusion of youth from political processes represents a critical governance challenge. Without civil society-driven platforms to amplify youth voices, political spaces remain dominated by older elites, reinforcing generational power imbalances.

 • Marginalized Communities and Political Disenfranchisement – Minority clans and marginalized communities have historically been excluded from political power. The lack of independent civil society organizations advocating for their rights has perpetuated systemic inequalities, limiting their access to political representation and decision-making forums.

Consequences for Governance and Stability
The absence of a strong civil society not only undermines political inclusion but also poses broader risks to governance and stability in Somalia. Without civil society acting as a watchdog, political processes remain elite-driven, reinforcing patronage networks and weakening public trust in government institutions. Furthermore, the lack of independent advocacy mechanisms reduces accountability, enabling human rights violations, corruption, and the erosion of democratic norms.

 Strengthening Civil Society for Democratic Consolidation
To foster a more inclusive and participatory political environment, deliberate efforts must be made to strengthen the role of civil society in Somalia. Key recommendations include:

 • Enhancing Legal and Institutional Protections – Establishing clear legal frameworks that safeguard the independence and operational space of civil society organizations is critical for their long-term sustainability.

 • Investing in Grassroots-Led Civil Society Initiatives – Donors and development partners should prioritize direct support for locally driven organizations that have legitimacy within communities, rather than favoring elite-controlled or internationally driven initiatives.

 • Expanding Civic Education and Political Awareness – Strengthening civic engagement through education programs can empower women, youth, and marginalized groups to participate more actively in political processes.

 • Creating Platforms for Multi-Stakeholder Engagement – Encouraging dialogue between civil society, government institutions, and political actors can facilitate greater collaboration and ensure that governance reforms reflect the interests of all segments of society.

 Conclusion
The absence of a strong and independent civil society in Somalia represents a major obstacle to inclusive governance and sustainable peace. Without a vibrant civic space advocating for the rights of women, youth, and marginalized communities, political processes will continue to be dominated by narrow elite interests. Strengthening civil society is not merely a democratic imperative—it is a necessary condition for achieving long-term stability and social cohesion in Somalia.

@TheSomaliDiary

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

"The Ripple Effect: How USAID Funding Cuts Threaten Somalia’s Fragile Stability"

By
Somalia’s Political, Security, and Economic Landscape  Somalia stands at a critical juncture, grappling with a complex mix of political instability, security threats, and economic fragility. The country, which has long suffered from civil conflict and weak governance structures, has made significant yet fragile progress in state-building. The federal government continues to struggle with power disputes among federal member states, clan-based rivalries, and delayed elections that hinder political stability.  On the security front, armed oppoaition groups remains a potent force, orchestrating frequent attacks on both civilian and military targets. Despite ongoing counterterrorism efforts by the Somali National Army (SNA) and the African Union Transition Mission in Somalia (ATMIS), the militant group maintains control over strategic areas, disrupting governance and humanitarian operations.  Economically, Somalia faces a daunting reality. With a heavy reliance on external a...
Post a Comment
Read more

The US Dollar A Common Currency In Somalia

By
The US dollar is a common currency in Somalia The US dollar is commonly used as a currency in Somalia, especially in urban areas and in international transactions. This is due to the instability of the Somali shilling, which has experienced significant inflation and devaluation over the years. The use of the US dollar in Somalia dates back to the early 1990s, when the country descended into civil war and the central government collapsed. Without a functioning central bank to issue and regulate its currency, Somalia has relied on foreign currencies, such as the US dollar, for trade and commerce. Additionally, many Somalis living abroad send remittances to their families in Somalia in US dollars, further contributing to the widespread use of the currency in the country. How has the use of the US dollar affected the Somali economy? The use of the US dollar in Somalia has had both positive and negative effects on the economy. Positive effects : - Stabilization: The US dollar has pro...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Constitution of Somalia Remains Draft More than A Decade

By
The draft Constitution of Somalia was developed by the Constitutional Commission between 2010 and 2012 and was approved by the National Constituent Assembly in August 2012. However, its adoption has been delayed due to political instability and disagreements between different political actors in Somalia. In fact, the process to finalize the draft Constitution of Somalia became long and complex one, with numerous challenges and obstacles that have prevented its completion. Some of the main reasons why Somalia has been unable to finalize the draft Constitution include: 1. Political instability: Somalia has been affected by political instability and conflict for many years, which has made it difficult to establish a stable government and political system. In such an environment, it can be challenging to build consensus on a new Constitution that reflects the needs and aspirations of all stakeholders. 2. Clan-based politics: Somalia's political system is based on clan affiliations, w...
Post a Comment
Read more

End of AU Mission - Is Somalia Ready?

By
Introduction : Background of the AU mission in Somalia, its mandate, achievements, and challenges. The African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) is a regional peacekeeping operation authorized by the United Nations Security Council in 2007 to support the Somali government in restoring peace and stability in the country. AMISOM’s mandate includes providing security for key institutions, facilitating humanitarian assistance, supporting the political process, and enabling the gradual transfer of security responsibilities to the Somali security forces. AMISOM has contributed to the liberation of most of the territory from the control of al-Shabaab, a militant Islamist group that has waged a violent insurgency against the Somali government and its allies. However, AMISOM has also faced many challenges, such as inadequate resources, logistical constraints, political divisions, human rights violations, and attacks from al-Shabaab and other armed groups. As of December 2023, AMISOM has about 1...
Post a Comment
Read more

"Ethiopia Joins AUSSOM: Balancing Allies and Rivalries in Somalia's Security Mission"

By
Ethiopia Joins AUSSOM Mission: A New Chapter in Somalia’s Security Landscape The African Union Transition Mission in Somalia (AUSSOM) has witnessed a significant development with the inclusion of Ethiopian troops among its contributing forces. This decision, the outcome of high-level discussions between the Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) and Ethiopia, marks a critical step in the evolving dynamics of Somalia’s security framework. Background of Ethiopia’s Engagement Ethiopia has historically played an active role in Somalia’s stability, both bilaterally and through multilateral mechanisms. The Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) have been involved in countering the Al-Shabaab insurgency for years, often operating outside the formal African Union mandate. However, their recent inclusion within the AUSSOM framework signals a more coordinated approach to peacekeeping in Somalia. The agreement followed strategic negotiations between Somalia's leadership and Ethiopia, emphasizi...
Post a Comment
Read more