Somalia's 4.5 Governance System is Failing..

The 4.5 governance system in Somalia is not succeeding in establishing a representative and inclusive democracy there as envisioned. The system, which was put in place in 2000 as a short-term measure to put an end to the civil war and distribute parliamentary seats among the four main clans and a coalition of minority groups, has come under fire for enforcing clan politics, marginalizing minorities and women, and undermining the legitimacy of the federal government. Nasteha Ahmed, a researcher at the American University in Cairo, claims that because the 4.5 system does not adequately represent the richness and complexity of Somali society, it has also failed to merge traditional and contemporary governing systems. Clan rivalry, corruption, nepotism, and violence, among other social characteristics that have historically sparked conflict, she contends, have persisted as a result of the system.

The 4.5 system was not included in the 2012 temporary constitution, which was meant to pave the way for the switch to a one-person, one-vote system by 2020. However, the constitutional review process has stopped and the electoral system has not been changed because of security issues, political disagreements, and a lack of agreement between federal and state authorities. As a result, the 4.5 system continued to be used for the 2017 presidential elections, with clan elders choosing the delegates who cast their votes for the members of parliament who subsequently chose the president. Allegations of vote buying, intimidation, and manipulation by outside parties tainted this process.

The 4.5 electoral system should be abolished in favor of a more democratic and inclusive election system that upholds human rights, gender equality, and citizenship, according to a number of academics, legislators, and members of Somali civil society. They have also argued in favor of a judicial service commission that may choose judges based on qualifications and integrity, as well as a constitutional court that can rule on constitutional and federalism-related disputes. For Somalia to overcome its political crises and attain stability, peace, and development, these measures are imperative.

Comments

"The Ripple Effect: How USAID Funding Cuts Threaten Somalia’s Fragile Stability"

Somalia’s Political, Security, and Economic Landscape Somalia stands at a critical juncture, grappling with a complex mix of political instability, security threats, and economic fragility. The country, which has long suffered from civil conflict and weak governance structures, has made significant yet fragile progress in state-building. The federal government continues to struggle with power disputes among federal member states, clan-based rivalries, and delayed elections that hinder political stability. On the security front, armed oppoaition groups remains a potent force, orchestrating frequent attacks on both civilian and military targets. Despite ongoing counterterrorism efforts by the Somali National Army (SNA) and the African Union Transition Mission in Somalia (ATMIS), the militant group maintains control over strategic areas, disrupting governance and humanitarian operations. Economically, Somalia faces a daunting reality. With a heavy reliance on external a...

The Somali Political Crisis Explained: Elections, Opposition, and Security Challenges

Somalia’s Current Political Standoff: A Nation at a Crossroads As Somalia’s current government approaches the final year of its term, the political landscape is becoming increasingly charged and complex. The return of opposition leaders to Mogadishu has injected new energy into the capital, signalling a resurgence of political activity and mobilisation that is impossible to ignore. This renewed opposition presence underscores the growing momentum of political gatherings and movements, reflecting a palpable shift in the country’s political dynamics. The Government’s Vision: One Person, One Vote In response to the evolving political climate, President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud, alongside Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre, the Speaker of the House of the People, and influential state leaders from Hirshabelle, Galmudug, and Southwest states, have announced the formation of a new political party. This coalition champions a transformative electoral vision grounded in the principle of “one man, one...

The US Dollar A Common Currency In Somalia

The US dollar is a common currency in Somalia The US dollar is commonly used as a currency in Somalia, especially in urban areas and in international transactions. This is due to the instability of the Somali shilling, which has experienced significant inflation and devaluation over the years. The use of the US dollar in Somalia dates back to the early 1990s, when the country descended into civil war and the central government collapsed. Without a functioning central bank to issue and regulate its currency, Somalia has relied on foreign currencies, such as the US dollar, for trade and commerce. Additionally, many Somalis living abroad send remittances to their families in Somalia in US dollars, further contributing to the widespread use of the currency in the country. How has the use of the US dollar affected the Somali economy? The use of the US dollar in Somalia has had both positive and negative effects on the economy. Positive effects : - Stabilization: The US dollar has pro...

"Proxy Power Plays: How Turkish and Emirati Private Military Deployments Signal a New Era of Militarized Influence in Somalia"

Somalia long a battleground for internal stability, is increasingly becoming a geopolitical chessboard for external powers. The recent arrival of Turkish-deployed private military personnel in the south and UAE affliated security contractors in the northeast—marks a dangerous escalation in the militarization of Somali soil. These developments signal not just a new chapter in Somalia’s complex security story, but a stark warning: global and regional powers are using Somalia as a base for proxy operations in broader regional conflicts. Turkey’s Strategic Deployment in the South Under the guise of bilateral defense cooperation, Turkey has deployed trained mercenaries, many with combat experience in Syria and Libya, to Somalia. While officially tasked with supporting counterterrorism operations against Al-Shabaab, their presence suggests a deeper mission: protecting Turkish economic and political interests, projecting military power along the Gulf of Aden, and countering adversaries...

🧭 The Walk of Shame for Going Back to the Tent

🧭 The Walk of Shame for Going Back to the Tent Somalia’s Elusive One Man, One Vote Dream 📅 Published: June 2025 ✍️ By The Somali Diary Introduction For a nation that has spent the better part of two decades trying to untangle itself from conflict, fragmentation, and fragile governance, the promise of “one man, one vote” in Somalia was always more than a procedural ambition. It was a symbolic return to full citizenship , a path toward dignity and democratic legitimacy. But as Somalia stumbles toward another election cycle, the reality has become stark: the country is once again walking back to the "tent" — the indirect, clan-based electoral model. This isn’t just a compromise. To many, it is a national embarrassment . A walk of shame . The Idealism of One Man, One Vote The administration of President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud came into office with a bold commitment to implement direct elections. In April 2023 , the Federal Government and four Federal Member States...

TheSomaliDiary

Search This Blog